I have not been to Edinburgh for more than 10 years. On finding out was returning I was thrilled at the prospect of having time to go to The Witchery again for dinner. I ended up booking a night there for 8 of us including colleagues from US and Germany. I was really disappointed by The Witchery it has lost... More

I think the restaurant did not live up to it's hype...for my money the food and service was better at the 'Tower' restaurant.

Enjoyed a wonderful, romantic anniversary lunch in the courtyard and ended up spending most of the afternoon there. Had the impression of being in a garden. Had a lovely window seat. Food was good without being too showy. Friendly and unobtrusive staff.

Lunch at the Witchery made my weekend special. We went for the 2 course light lunch and were not disappointed, but its the skill of the waiting on team that make this special - discreet, quiet, yet personable. Its not often you see this level of service - impeccable.

If you are looking for a really unique place to go in Edinburgh, give this a try. Try and get a table in the lower area, it is more cozy and romantic. The food and service is excellent and most of the menu comes from local producers too. Good stuff!

My parents were over for Mother's Day from America, my mom was so excited to enjoy this beautiful restaurant after a day of sightseeing in Edinburgh. Most of us ordered the pre theatre menu which included a starter and a main for £15.99. Now I have been to high end restaurants before, I understand portion size in these types of... More

I had heard great things about this place and the images on line certainly seem to agree with the tales. upon arrival to the secret garden we were treated to a first class experience from all the staff and the food was some of the best ive ever had. the staff were formal yet freindly, the decor was amazing and... More

Atmosphere is a difficult thing to create but this place has oodles of it. The food and wine were incredible and service exceptional. Definitely going to re-visit Edinburgh just to try the restaurant again.

I visited with a group of friends and we chose the 3 course set menu for £33. Between us we tried everything - even the dull veggie option of cauliflower cheese- and it was entirely average. Certainly not what we expected given this restaurant's reputation for fine dining. We had agreed to return the table by 9 and at 845... More