Dined in the Secret Garden restaurant during our overnight stay in the Armoury Suite (see seperate review). Whilst I had absolutely no reservations about the standard of accomodation at the Witchery (which turned out to be even better than I expected) I did have some advance concerns after reading some of the Reviews on Tripadvisor about my potential "dining experience".... more

I went to the Witchery for a special Christmas lunch with two friends. Having been to the Tower and Prestonfield House (both in the same ownership) I had high hopes of this visit. The 24 hours prior reminder of the booking should have alerted me. The lady who phoned was curt and singularly lacking in charm. On arrival, we were... more

Excellent service and the food is the best! Look carefully for the door, it's hidden because this is not a run of the mill restaurant. Medieval atmosphere and special attention to the details make this place a dining experience. Not for those on a budget. You will get your money's worth, though. Your meal is presented, not just served and... more

When I told friends I was going to Edinburgh they said you have to eat in the Witchery it's fantactic, so I booked a table. It was my boyfriends birthday I asked if they could arrange a cake or something they said no but would arrange a candle for his desert unfortunately nothing happened and it was a bit disappointing... more

The prices on this review are incorrect. The meals generally start in the 40 GBP range, not the $30-50 range. To spend $200+ on a meal, I expect better service. I expect a waiter who is old enough to have actually tried the wine (legally) and make a suggestion about a pairing, experienced enough to discuss the food knowledgeably, old... more

The French Matre de needs to lose the down the nose attitude and be more observant of his whole restaraunt not just his favourites. On the other hand our waitress was fantastic. The food was good although disappointing, i had the seafood platter and realise we are spoilt in Australia, the local chip shop would of been preferred. It was... more

My hubby and I were a bit worried that we had booked the Witchery after reading some of the reviews. But we are really glad we igonred all the bad ones. What a night. The service was good but unintrusive. The food was excellent. The menu was changing the day after we were there and a few things were substitued... more

What an interesting place to go to - very unusual/interesting themed restaurant. Top class service and Fabulous food. Well worth a visit although it isnt cheap! more

I've been to the Witchery on a couple of occasions, both times for the set price lunch. I have to say I was very excited to be going as I had heard good things about the place but it was a bit of a disappointment. Although the setting is very beautiful and the staff were very professional, it was let... more