After several days worth of disappointing meals in Aspen, this place was the highlight. We grew up on Chicago-style pizza and consider any good pizza our favorite comfort food. New York Pizza was absolutely yummy! The decor is funky (and the place not just a little dirty). We'd recommend ordering a pizza for take-out, as it's quite crowded and loud... more

This is a small, funky-ish pizza place hidden up a set of stairs. The prices were reasonable for Aspen, although our two (large) pieces of pizza, one large salad, and two beers were about $22. The pizza was good, but not epic. more

This is a great little pizza place. We ate here one night just to cut down on our dinning out bill a bit. Yes, Aspen can be expensive to dine, but that's what it's all about. So, eat here once, maybe twice during your stay and then splurg at the better places in town. The pizza is really good too!! more

The best pizza I've had in Colorado (I'm from NJ)! It's kind of fun because it's a little hidden in an uptairs location. Very friendly and the price is right! more