Good beer and den food in a darkened den-like atmosphere. They had scrod the day I was there but their menu is usually pretty simple. More

My husband and I had great burgers here and tasty winter seasonal beers! It is a dark, old bar and we liked that atmopsphere. More

We went to enjoy the atmosphere of a 200 year old bar, but were left a bit disappointed. Yes, it is slightly dark and moody, but the clientele let it down, single middle aged men glumly browsing email on their blackberries and iPhones.... College kids eating burgers... it kinda ruined the atmosphere. Not really the Brotherhood's fault, but we didn't... More

My friend and I had lunch at the Brotherhood. We ate at the bar in the lower level which our server told us was original to the building - very cool, old whaler ambiance. We both had delicious burgers - mine was the blue cheese burger and it was out of this world ! ! ! More

My friends suggested we stop in and try one of the best burgers we will ever eat.. She was right... Ice cold beer, and great food. The bartender was great, very helpful and witty. she suggested a few places to go after we finished our lunch. We will definitely go back the next time we're on Nantucket.. More

Our guide to Nantucket (Ara) recommended the place to us at the end of the tour and she did good - We loved it. The restaurant is furnished like an ancient whalers' pub, cozy and authentic-looking. The service was friendly and efficient. We took the fried goat cheese and the lobster bisque (Yummy!!) for starters, followed by incredible fried calamaris... More

This was our second time eating lunch at the Brotherhood and we weren't disappointed. Great food and great service :) More

When there for lunch and the burgers and beers were great. Has a true 'olde Nantucket' feel that is great to get if visiting for the day. More

food was well prepared; we did know to bring a flashlight to read the menu and it still was difficult. crowded table and ok service More