I NEVER order a steak at the beach but as we went in to this tiny restaurant we ran into local friends who raved about the steak. It was late and they were out of one of the specials so we both ordered the very pricey steak. It was stuffed with cheese and sundried tomatoes and it was heavenly. We'll... more

We ate at the restaurant in mid-March, low season, and called to see if we needed reservations, per other reviews. We were told no reservation was needed. When we arrived, it was as expected, small and charming. Forewarned of the space issue, we took a seat and looked forward to the cuisine. Yes, the filet mignon is excellent, although it... more

Dinner at the Island Grille turned out to be one of the best I have ever had -- thoroughly enjoyable and scrumptous. While the Grille is compact, the service is supberb and the wine list marvelous. I had the stuffed filet mignon which I can't say enough good things about. Next year when I return for vacation I will most... more

Great food...especially on the two for one nights. Only negative is how small the place is. Make sure you make a reservation. more

The Grille was very tight for a family of five, their 2 for 1 specials were very misleading because you can not order from the normal menu, you have to order from their "special" menu. These prices are at least $10 more than their normal menu. The price for a kid pasta with six shrimp was $12, a complete rip-off.... more

It was not a pleasant experience. It was pretty hot inside, combined with a cramped atmosphere. The portions were small, but the food was very good. The service was the biggest problem. While the waitress was very friendly, she only stopped by the table about every 20 minutes. It took over 30 minutes for our food to come out, and... more

Very good place to eat!! more

My husband, son, and I dined at the Island Grille the first night that we arrived in Atlantic Beach in June 2008. We got there when they opened at 5 PM so we were their first customers. It was a Sunday evening and by the time we left around 6 PM only one other table was occupied. The lady that... more

We went here a few days after Memorial Day on a Wednesday night and it was almost completely empty. We had basically the restaurant to ourselves, which coupled with the rain gave it a warm atmosphere. Our server was very nice and helpful. The food was good, but the menu describes fancy-sounding items that end up being pretty simple. Definitely... more