I found the place dark and filled with kitschy clutter...the menu is so vast, our party didn't know what the specialty of the house was. Prices are very high and the quality average...very salty, and the pizza was very bad. We wanted to like this place but won't be back. more

After hearing rave reviews and recommendations for this place, we finally tried it. The good. Upon arrival we were promptly seated and were provided with our drinks and bread. A few minutes later Bill (the owner) came to the table and greeted us. Very friendly and the ambiance was fantastic. The not so good... After two refills of drinks (approx.... more

Excellent pasta, good sauces, interesting decor, friendly owners. A little pricey, but good food. more

This was our second trip and I couldn't wait to return after our trip over a year ago. The food was delicioust; we devoured the white pizza. Our entrees were delicious. The service was good-not overpowering. I was tickled that the owner took time again to visit our table and asked us to sign his guest book but not surprised-he... more

The name of this restaurant caught our attention on our first visit to the area and then our friends insisted that we would have a great Italian meal. The restaurant has an extensive menu with a section devoted to lamb dishes but we had salads, pizza and chicken with dumplings. All were excellent. Truly some of the best pizza I... more

The only reason we eat in Cath. city Absolutely great dishes and very fresh. We are locals and critical and we can't find a thing to complain about. The bread and dipping sauce they bring at first is a reason all in itself to go!!! You wont be sorry you went. more

We went here on our last night and wished we had gone earlier to be able to make a second dinner. The lamb shank was about one of the best I had. The decor is quite different and I enjoyed looking at all the fun pictures, camereas, etc. The owner was stopping at all the tables to make sure everyone... more

We head to the Red Tomato House of Lamb frequently during our winter stay. It has a wonderful cozy feel to it especially in the patriotic front room with Dorothy and Toto on either side of the door. We love the staff - they are fun, friendly, and attentive. the lamb dishes are a little spicy but very good. When... more

I often crave The Red Tomato's Beef Stroganof . . . it's served with these thick noodles . . . really quite unique. Once I had it with fettucine and that was great! There is no way I can finish the whole plate, though . . . Because they serve the most delicious pizza bread with garlic butter and a... more