Unfriendly atmosphere. Waiter seem irritable even though we didn't burden them with questions or complaints. Very average food. Only go there if you are starving and the other places are full. more

Tony's offers consistenly excellent fresh seafood. The mussels are served in a nice clam flavored broth, the fish tacos and sole are great. If they have not run out of crab be sure to try that. The BBQ oysters are great. Skip the salad and fries and just get the fish - ask the wait staff what they recommend. Wine... more

This is your typical seafood shack catering to the tourists driving up and down US-1 in Marsall, California. The food is OK and they only serve beer and wine. The service was OK. You're on the water but the interior of the restaurant is nothing to rave about. more

This place has a great kitschy seaside ambience and friendly service. We thought the prices were high for the mediocre food. (Entrees in the $17 - $20 range) All the fish was very fresh, but not prepared with any flair. We started with BBQ oysters, which were good themselves but had too much not very interesting sauce. (For great BBQ... more

The food here was O.K., I guess. If the prices were cut in half, this place would still be overcharging for the quality of food they serve. I gave this place 2 stars instead of 1 because it's not like the food made me ill, it just wasn't worth the prices they charged. more

Holy Crow, what are people expecting? Sterling silver flatware? This place is a historical venue. Anton, the owner, has taken over for his dad - you got it - Tony. The local flavor is unbeatable and the oysters to die for - shucked right in the front of the building. If you are looking for ahi tuna tartar you might... more

Not sure what people have said about the service, but we had excellent service on Saturday afternoon. It was busy, and not just locals, everyone goes there. This resturant is listed in the book "1000 places to see before I die", for a reason. There famous for oysters, fresh seafood, and the quanity of the food. This is not a... more

I see two reviews with ratings of 5 for Tony's but I can only assume that because they are old reviews, something major has changed since 2006 that has caused this place to go to hell. My husband and I went to Tony's upon a recommendation from the staff at Motel Inverness. I believed it and was taken in by... more

Location, view, service and excellent oysters....it doesn't get any better than this! more