Comfortable, friendly atmosphere with high quality food! I've been there many times and am never disappointed.
I've enjoyed everything ever ordered here (3 cheese small plate, grilled octopus, salmon, "pig roast", creme brûlée for 4) and the service is terrific! Kudos to our server Emalie tonight who was totally on the spot with more wine, bread , etc. Be sure you have reservations on a Sat nite because this place is POPULAR!
We've been married for 2 years now- and on our wedding we had the big nor-easter, then last year Hurricane Sandy. So this year we celebrated our anniversary and the weather. We go to this restaurant 2x a year and it is always good. My husband and I had the specials, homemade ribbon pasta with schrimp with a penne vodka... More
Terrible experience with flies in this restaurant, a manager who didn't care, and food that was mediocre at best. This used to be the best restaurant in town. Went downhill quickly. Not sure why.
I know this place gets rave reviews. Went for a family celebration. Waitress was great... nothing her fault. However, manager was unwilling to accommodate dietary needs without a $6.50 charge/pp. Ridiculous! Drinks very overpriced for size. Food was decent but not wonderful. Zuppa de pesce was a lot of pasta... too much for fish in it. Any many clams were... More
My husband and I have been coming here for dinner 1 - 2 times a month for many years and we love it. The staff is great - attentive and friendly, and the food is consistently wonderful. A few of our favorite dishes are the balsamic calamari appetizer (don't want to know how many calories are in this, but worth... More
This was our first visit to Carl Anthony's. We found the restaurant nicely decorated without being overdone. The staff was friendly and attentive without being overbearing. They were right there if we needed anything, but they let us have a relaxing dinner and definitely did not rush us at all. The food was beautifully prepared and tasted great. The broccoli... More
I've been going to this restaurant for many years (not just in April 2013) and never gave it the kudos it deserves, so I finally decided to write a review. I've lived in Newtown for 15 yrs and I have yet to find a local restaurant that is better! The food is always fresh and delicious with a great variety... More
I went to Carl Anthony’s as part of business dinner. There were 9 of us that arrived around 6:00 pm on a Thursday evening. As we walked in, the bar area was packed with a large group seeming to be there for a celebration, but we were seated quickly. The waiter took our drink orders. He came back shortly with... More
If you own or manage Carl Anthony's Trattoria, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing