This is a nice change of pace from alot of the overpriced tourist trap restaurants in the area. Soup and sandwiches are terrific. We can't wait to go back! more

I have been twice and both times loved the panini but thought the soups were just OK. The fresh tuna salad panini is spectacular. But the Potato Leek soup was bland and uninteresting. The Asiago overpowered the tomato in the Roast Tomato and Asiago Cheese soup, and on the day it was offered the other soup choice was Broccoli Cheddar,... more

After reading a review on this page, my husband and I checked out this place while in town. It was the first panini my husband ever had and he said it was the best sandwich he's ever had in his life! We're visiting CT again in December and let's just say the only thing we definitely have on our to-do... more

This place is amazing! Always good to find a new lunch place when you work in the Mystic area. After being sick of the same 'ole and hearing word on the street that this hidden jem was just that- a jem, we tried it for lunch. What more to say than AWESOME! Try the soups AND sandwiches, can't even decide... more

I've been to Mystic Soup Co. about five times and never gotten soup. The panini's are too good and filling to even need the soups, which my friends tell me are also phenomenal. It is obvious that the meat they use is fresh and it isn't cut into small slices, it is in large portions. Very fair pricing, eight bucks... more

Mystic's hidden treasure! Never knew it was there until a friend led me to it. The soups and sandwiches are amazing and exactly what this area needed! Get on their email list and the specials will be sent right to your inbox! Located behind and to the right of Sea Swirl. MUST CHECK IT OUT!!! more