Very poor service and while it promised freshly cooked food, our fillet steak when ordered 'blue' then came back well done. It had clearly been microwaved. The waitress apologised but we left and went to rice spice thai restaurant. Much better! Avoid this blatantly below par eaterie. more

The salmon was great, however, the chicken marsala should have been served with a soup ladle, life jacket and a side of Lipitor. My food was submerged in a underprepared sauce in which the fat/butter was separating before my eyes. Truly inedible! After 30-mins of trying to get the waitress to come back to the table and explaining the problem,... more

Recently my husband and I traveled through Mystic on business and pleasure. The first night we dined at S&P Oyster house, which was okay, but very noisy and slow service. Since parking is a premium, we parked several blocks away and walked by Anthony J's on the way to the other restaurant. I joked with my hubby that we should... more

This place is very small on the inside, and tables are very close to each other. We went pretty early on a Saturday night, around 5:30, but by the time we were leaving there was a wait to get a table. But the food makes up for all of that. The regular menu looked pretty standard, Italian pasta and meat... more

Granted it was a friday night, no reservations, we expected a wait, BUT, the chaos inside, no room to actually wait, the hostess saying twice "I'll be right back", did not leave a good taste. Other people, obviously known, were seated ahead, although we were first. Hmmm. Not a warm feeling for a tourist area. We left, S&P never fails. more

Great little italian restaurant. Cozy and romantic! more

Overpriced, overhyped. Went their twice the first time was decent, a year later when I went a second time, the food was bland and totally not worth finishing. more

As part of their winter special, for a grand total of $39.95 we got a 3 course dinner for 2 people and a good bottle of wine. The portions were generous, and to my pleasant surprise the quality of the food and its preparation was very, very good. Our waitress was courteous and attentive, yet was not intrusive. For the... more

Great food. Had delicious lamb chops. Small, quiet atmosphere. more