where else can you get an american cheese pie? more

Best pizza, hands down. Pepe's is also good and runs a close second but for me, there is just something better about the sauce at Modern. Fast service, great value! more

New Haveners fall into three camps: Pepe's, Sally's, or Modern. In our house, she prefers Modern; he prefers Pepe's. We both agree, that service is faster and friendlier at Modern and the line at Modern is sometimes shorter. Modern is as good or better than Pepe's in most catagories, although we give the white clam pie award to Pepe's. Sally's... more

Always worth the wait! more

I grew up in New Haven and always thought Modern was way better than Pepe's and Sally's. The sauce is key. It is not bitter or pasty. I live in California now but am back in CT at least once a year. I always pay Modern a visit! Sometimes I even buy a pizza, freeze it, and take it back... more

We took out their pizza. Our relatives go all the way from North Haven because they love it so much. I was anxious to try their pizza, and was glad we did! The crust is thin and crisp, and the ingredients and red sauces are authentic and delicious. Ingredients are thinly layered on top of the pie- it reminded me... more

I'd rate Modern third out of New Haven's top pizza places. I should add that New Haven really does have the best pizza in the USA. That may be hard to believe for some outsiders but have a taste and then I think you will agree! I'd put Pepes and Sallies (both of Wooster St - New Haven) ahead of... more

great pizza, nothing like New Haven Pizza more

18" was plenty for 2 adults and 2 teenagers. Thin crust. Popular with everyone. Good atmosphere and prompt service. Recommended and would definitely go again. Reasonably priced. more