It may not be modern, but the people are friendly and the food is caught by their own boats, so it is good quality. They do not over charge for the drinks which makes a change in most restaurants in the US. We will go make again for the Snow Crab Claws, but will wear a more basic top to... more

We got the calamari, lobster fritters and the oysters Rockefeller (we made a meal out of appetizers many times while in Ft Myers Beach) The lobster fritters were all frit and no lob. Oysters were fine, but not note worthy. But the calamari, oh, the calamari. Melted in my mouth. Realized what calamari is supposed to be. Perfect. more

I discovered this lovely little restaurant after reading reviews on TA and was not disapointed. My parent's, two sisters and I went on the half day fishing trip out of Capt. Tony's and caught 25 small/medium spottail fish and had them fileted on the boat. We then took our catch to the Fishmonger where they fried them up for us... more

This being our 7th night on the island, I have to say our meal tonight was the absolute BEST we had so far on our trip. The waitress explained the specials menu and gave great recommendations on not only appetizers but main course. For our appetizers we had Mary's Calamari with lemon butter - OUTSTANDING and so fresh and we... more

My mother often told me it's not what on the outside that matters, but what's on the inside. We've been to Fort Myers Beach for several annual trips. We've driven by the Fishmonger many times on each trip... it's on the main road. The outside of the restaurant is not very inviting and has detered us from going in. This... more

We were searching for a place to eat,and had decided to use a discount coupon just to save a little money,so we tried Fishmongers.Even without a discount coupon i'd go back again and again.The food is worth the money.The atmosphere was perfect,the food excellent,the staff very friendly. more

This was fun to eat here, we bought t-shirts and sweatshirts....great little old structure and fun atmosphere. But....we prefer fresh broiled and grilled fish...and a healthier menu. If you like fried food, tartar sauce and more of a "bar food" sort of food, this is the place for you. VERY poor wine selection. more

Was told staff was rude. However, did not find that at all on Wednesday, April 8, 2009. Food was good. Service very good. Restaurant filled not only with tourists, but with locals. more

We pass this restaurant every year on our way to the hotel. We like to stay on the island for most of our meals. This year we decided to dine at some new places and found the Fishmonger to be an excellent choice. My wife and I both had seafood, shrimp & scallops for me and a fish special for... more