It's tough to impress us, as Floridians who have access to outstanding Cuban food on a regular basis, but we had to try, as this is a Tripadvisor favorite (we went against the advice of a local). It's a fun "hold in the wall" family restaurant, which we love. It is lacking on cleanliness (floor was dirty- hate to think... more

Best Cuban food! Put this on your list of places that you HAVE to try! You will not leave here unhappy! Ask the locals about it! You will hear nothing negative! more

We were recommended this restaurant by our Concierge at the hotel. We walked over to the restaurant and enjoyed going through the residential area and relaxing in the start of the evening. This is obviously a hidden gem - the restaurant was bustling with take out and filled up with in-house diners while we were there. We enjoyed the Cuban... more

El Siboney is off the beaten path, in a residential section of town. This place is no-frills for sure and is very casual. We were seated right away and waited on quickly. Our waitress was pleasant. The food came quickly and was delicious. My husband had the roast pork with yellow rice, plantains and black beans. I had the "combo"... more

We like this restaurant very much. It is authentic, good Cuban food. No question. But on our most recent visit we were traveling with 2 other couples neither of which had ever been to Key West before and we only had 3 days. The ambience at El Siboney is probably very Cuban, very Mom's home cooking-ish. Nothing wrong with it,... more

The food is tasty, served hot, served quickly and the prices are very reasonable. My wife and I had lunch there on Sunday and we were both delighted with our choices. I had the Pepper Steak which was a generous portion of strips of top sirloin, sauteed with onions and green peppers and simmered in a pan gravy, accompanied by... more

Wonderfully authentic Cuban cuisine! We arrived around 12:30 on a Sunday, ordered our food and I went to the restroom to wash my hands. Just as I returned, our food arrived - wow! My husband had the sunday special - Pepper Steak. So savory. I had the pork, tamale and cassava. Fantastic! I hadn't had cassava before - basically a... more

Ate dinner here and was very impressed. Price was very reasonable and good food. 3 of us had fish and one had pork. It was all good. Sangria was wonderful. Be sure to get it! more

This family owned & operated place is just perfect for lunch. I had grilled mahi, yellow rice, black beans & sweet plantains. My husband had the same except w/ snapper. We also had a half carafe of yummy sangria. Everything is fresh, delicious, and served up fast! Total bill with tip: $40.69 more