For steak and lobster, this is the most recommended restaraunt in Key West. It is fine dining, with an enjoyable view, relaxing elegant atmosphere, and excellent service. more

We wanted a nice meal that was a little dressy. We got fair food with a poor waiter that had the hold dining room to himself. He tried hard, it was impossible to wait on that many tables. I had the snapper and it was good and my guest had a filet and it was good more

We were married in Key West on June 15, 09. We ate at teh Commodore for our wedding dinner. The service was exceptional and attentive. Our crab and avocado cocktail was wonderfully light and refreshing. The lobster in the Captain's Platter was a little tough but the rest of the dish was fantastic...thought it would be tail when it was... more

Love the food, the view and service. The escargot, filet mignon and desserts are excellent. Love it! more

We were vacationing with another couple for a long birthday weekend and I was in charge of the restaurant selections for our 4 day stay. Commodore's was our first night choice and it was a wonderful meal. We arrived early for the reservation and thought we would sit at the bar, which was empty , and order a cocktail. The... more

I have lost 42 pounds during the past 11 months by making good choices.  But.... I love good food.  When I booked my reservation I asked what their policy was on sharing plates.  They had no problem at all.  We arrived and were seated at a corner table, with a lovely lady named Milka as our server.  My hubby and... more

We had eaten at the A&B Lobster house 2 evenings previous (which is right next door) so we were curious as to how the Commodore faired against the excellent meal at A&B. The funny thing was, I made reservations for the Commodore for our anniversary night, mistakenly believeing that it was there that we had eaten 2 yearws ago. I... more

My husband and I went there with my sister and her fiance'. We were celebrating my sister's engagement. My future brother-in-law made the reservations, and explained the circumstance's of our visit. We were given a private table out on the balcony overlooking the waterfront. The food was excellent, the service (Joseph) was impeccable and friendly. The entire experience was very... more

We just came back from dining here. This was a nice surprise as we did not have any reservation and chose it a bit randomly. It's pricey, but well at par with (or better than) some other good restaurants I've eaten all over the country Both appetizers were very good (shrimp cocktail and crab cake with avocado). The entrees were... more