I recently celebrated my 50th birthday with 5 friends at Prime. We were greeted promptly and given a choice of seating. We picked a booth, which I would recommend for parties of 6. The service was prompt, friendly and attentive without being intrusive. (I think our server's name was Michael). My wife and I split the New York Strip -... more

My wife and myself found this little gem of a restaurant after reading about it on tripadvisor, it is tucked away in a quiet part of Caroline Street but is well worth looking for. We went on a Wednesday night and the restaurant was fairly quiet so we were seated immediately. Good, easy to understand menu with the server offering... more

After a dozen trips to this island, we've tried a pretty good sampling of what Key West has to offer, and Prime wins hands-down. Everything was perfect, from the appetizers right through the after-dinner drinks. The bread was crusty and crisp, which is almost impossible to find in Florida. The filet mignon was fork-tender and was as good as any... more

As a Local of Key West I do a lot of dining out. Prime 951 is one of my favorite haunts. The food is great. I love the escargot, carpaccio and the bone-in ribeye. You have to have a side of the truffled mac and cheese, it's crazy good! Service is always personable and attentive. They are all great but... more

Fabulous everything. Steak was incredible...full of flavor. Lobster was well priced and portions were large. We shared the stake and lobster and we were stuffed. The service was first class and the atmosphere was romantic. I celebrated a special birthday there, and they made me feel like a queen. It was the perfect restaurant. more

My husband and I visit Key West annually, and we never miss the opportunity to dine at Prime Steakhouse...it is our favorite restaurant on the island! We love everything about this restaurant ~ the food, the service, the atmosphere. This is truly a dining experience that you won't want to miss! more

My husband and I were celebrating our 38th Wedding Anniversary on September 24th, 2009. The STEAKS were cooked to PERFECTION! The asparagus was delicious and the sweet potato soufflé was delicous. more

It's the Key's you expect Ok food in most of the places but never did I expect to find this quality of food, service and atmosphere hidden away here on Caroline in Key West. I had the bone in rib eye with the marsala sauce also the stack with tomatoes. I was once 410 LBS and let me tell you... more

Do not miss this great restaurant while in Key West. The best steaks in Key West more