We had a great lunch at Sarabeth's - “Cobb” Salad with substituted grilled fresh Mahi and a Griddled Smoked Mozzarella Sandwich, on the patio. The salad was very fresh, fish was cooked perfectly, great presentation. The sandwich was also grilled perfectly and was a lovely combination - the jicama side was nice and would have been a nice addition to... more

My husband and I visited Key West for the weekend of 10/24/09. We ate at Sarabeth's twice for breakfast. We tried the Key West shrimp & bacon omelet, 3 pepper potatoes, 4 flowers juice, coffee, and 8 grain toast. The service was very good and all of the ingredients were high quality. Yummy! Highly recommend. more

This is a fantastic breakfast place! Lemon Ricotta Pancakes are as delicious as they are beautiful. Not cheesy, just fluffy, moist and light. My husband had the pink shrimp and bacon omelet. So flavorful and loaded with large chunks of shrimp! The service was impeccable and quaint surroundings. We sat inside with a nice view of the courtyard and street.... more

My boyfriend and his Father ate her e on our last morning in the Keys, I only wish we had found it sooner. David Case, the proprietor is just as lovely as the restaurant! The food is both imaginative and delicious. We ordered the pink shrimp, cheese and bacon omlett and the almond crusted french toast with apple butter as... more

My husband and I had breakfast here on our last visit and it was superb!! The lemon ricotta pancakes are to die for!! The french toast is excellent too!! more

Very nice Key West atmosphere in an old church. Exceptionally good food for breakfast lunch and dinner. Compared to the average Key West restaurant this place has a little more class. Eat outside or in, service is great. Excellent food quality lives up to it's heritage which was transplanted from Manhattan. Try this one. more

This restaurant is wonderful. From the atmosphere to the creative menu - it is not to be missed. The Crab & Shrimp cakes are unbelievable! The owner and the staff made you feel like family. You can not go wrong with this place!! more

I spent a week in Key West in July of 09 and discovered SaraBeth's on my walk one morning. I stopped in and had breakfast outside and went back three times that week. Incredible breakfast with very nice service and great place to sit outside before the heat of the day. I highly recommend this, however, it is a bit... more

Sarabeth's is an adorable little restaurant in an old church building. It is off the main drag and offers indoor and outdoor seating. If you go you MUST have the dessert - their chocolate pudding, key lime pie, and strawberry shortcake were the best desserts on the island. Also, try their champagne cocktails (Sultry Night was my fav). On Sunday... more