i've had breakfast and lunch here, and both meals were decent. i found the prices to be very high, considering the location and quantity of food (or lack thereof). the servers are very nice and the owner usually greets you at the door, which is a rare treat, but there are many better restaurants with better atmosphere in KW. more

I had just arrived to Key West around 1:00 on Friday afternoon and wanted to check out Sarabeths. I am glad I did as it made a wonderful first impression on my wife & I. We had the Lemon Ricotta Pancakes and the Griddled Mozzarella Sandwich w/Four Flowers Juice and we were left amazed. The outside dining is great for... more

Ever since it opened Sarabeth's has been our favorite place for breakfast. We love the food, location, sitting outside and the personal service; David Case has done a tremendous job. We just got back from Key West and dined at Sarabeth's several times while there . Once you go you will want to go back - especially after the shrimp... more

Visited Sarabeth's for brunch as I had read all the reviews and were not disappointed. We sat out in the courtyard and ate our omellettes which were spectacular. Our waitress was pleasant and friendly and service was prompt. Definitely recommend this place for those who want to have a good breakfast/brunch and not interested in going to the diners with... more

Ate a late dinner at Sarabeth's (9pm), and was very glad with our choice. The outdoor dining was classy and relaxing. My strip steak and my wife's yellowfin snapper were outstanding. My wife did fine the wine a bit warmer than it should have been, but I didn't notice it. The bruschetta appetizer was excellent as well. Would definitely go... more

Exceptional food ... our lunch was great ... The pumpkin mufin was moist and not too sweet. and their bread is "to die for". The tuna salad was out of this world. We had super meals and super service! A must see in Key West. more

We ate at many places over 3 days in Key West, but our Saturday brunch at Sarabeth's was our favorite! We wanted to have brunch at Sarabeth's in New York City on a recent trip, but were unable to. We were excited to see one in Key West that was highly reviewed. I don't know how this compares to the... more

We ate here for breakfast. We were the first ones there at 8am. Very friendly service. We sat on the patio. I ordered the pumpkin waffle and my husband had the almond cursted Frech Toast. They were both out of this world. The presentation of the dishes were so nice. I also tried there homemade pumpkin muffin. This place reminds... more

in nyc, sarabeth's is great. in key west, even better. the owner is usually there welcoming EVERYONE.he knows what he is doing. i have been many times in the past couple of years, everytime has been a pleasure. GO TO SARABETHS!! more