To find the best spot, go where the locals go - that would be Craig's. The huge sign is correct - this was the very best sandwich I have ever had! We had a group of 8, and everyone agreed this was the best meal (price and quality) of our week in Islamorada. Do yourself (and your wallet) a favor... more

Unless you are a Turkey Vulture, and enjoy partially decomposed food, skip this place. The over priced hamburger with a salad, consisted of brown slimey lettuce, and raw, not rare chopped meat. We waited about 45 minutes for this. We did order some some thing else, (eggs) and they did not charge us for the burger salad, however, do not... more

If you can look past the Denny's meets Red Lobster ambiance, the food, service, and prices are wonderful. Best grouper sandwhich I have ever had, and under $10. The conch chowder was far superior than other local restaurants more

Three words. Go To Craig's. It is right on Route 1. It is a large sign that says World Famous Fish sandwich. I had the pleasure to sit down and chat with Craig about small business. He is a great guy. Sit down and tell him you are there. You foodies out there do not be disappointed by the dining... more

We ate here when we first arrived in Islamorada. We both had salads with cajun chicken. They were really good, but mostly iceberg lettuce which is cheap. About a week later we decided to go again. We got a chicken parm sandwich which was good and the fish sandwich which was excellent. The chicken parm was not breaded and the... more

It's a local place with friendly wait staff. The fish sandwich they advertise as world famous on billboards is moist and flavorful. more

We ordered take-out because the restaurant was closed for a private Rotary Club Meeting. After reading the reviews we wanted to try the fish sandwiches. They weren't that great, actually, a bit bland. We wouldn't return to eat there again. more

We ate at Craigs in 8/08 after spending a day snorkeling out of Key Largo.The dress is very casual(bathing suits) and the atmosphere pleasant.When they advertise as the best fish sandwich in the Keys,they aren't kidding. more

I had to laugh....I have been coming to the Keys for years and always saw the billboard "World Famous Fish Sandwich" and "Worlds Best Fish Sandwich" I chuckled and drove by...until the last two times I went there and stopped in.... Let me tell you the fish sandwich (your choice of mahi mahi, grouper, or yellow tail) was the greatest... more