We live in Flagler Beach and always eat fish when we go out. Craig's World Famous Fish Sandwich is for sure the very best. We stopped there last year on our way to Key West. We are going back down there next week. And Craig's is where we will be stopping for lunch.... The very best.. Linda & Jim Flagler... more

Nothing fancy - just good food, decent selection, friendly staff. Yes, the fish sandwich is excellent. Independent restos are still superior to the chains and this proves the point. more

Craig's has the BEST fish sandwich in the Keys. If you go during the day, ask for Linda. She's the nicest waitress. We can't wait to come back next year. more

I know everyone talks about the fish sandwich and most everyone in the Keys is looking for good seafood. Well, I'm not a big seafood eater. I was very happy to find Craig's with their 4 page menu featuring everything from soup and salad to grilled cheese, pasta, and filet mignon. What a choice!! My son and I ordered the... more

Their fish sandwich consists of mahi or catfish on a toasted whole wheat bread and can only be described as fantastic. I was in Key Largo/Islamorada for a few days and this was one of the best places we ate, period. I cannot vouch for anything except for the fish sandwich, but it is worth a stop if you like... more

To find the best spot, go where the locals go - that would be Craig's. The huge sign is correct - this was the very best sandwich I have ever had! We had a group of 8, and everyone agreed this was the best meal (price and quality) of our week in Islamorada. Do yourself (and your wallet) a favor... more

Unless you are a Turkey Vulture, and enjoy partially decomposed food, skip this place. The over priced hamburger with a salad, consisted of brown slimey lettuce, and raw, not rare chopped meat. We waited about 45 minutes for this. We did order some some thing else, (eggs) and they did not charge us for the burger salad, however, do not... more

If you can look past the Denny's meets Red Lobster ambiance, the food, service, and prices are wonderful. Best grouper sandwhich I have ever had, and under $10. The conch chowder was far superior than other local restaurants more

Three words. Go To Craig's. It is right on Route 1. It is a large sign that says World Famous Fish sandwich. I had the pleasure to sit down and chat with Craig about small business. He is a great guy. Sit down and tell him you are there. You foodies out there do not be disappointed by the dining... more