We had no idea what we were walking in to when we arrived at the Atlantic's Edge. We knew when we pulled up that we finally found (probably) the nicest restaurant in Islamorada and Key Largo. A warning: If high prices dissapoint - stay away. This restaurant is not cheap. It is however worth the prices. We had a great... more

I was on vacation from July 1st to July 8th 2007. I went to Cheeca Lodges' Atlantic Edge Restaurant. The bill came up to well over $300. The food was luke warm when it came out. I had the lobster potstickers for an appetizer and it was cold. Tasted horrible too. I then had the rack of lamb and they... more

After reading varied opinions on this restaurant, my wife and I decided to give it a shot during a recent get-away weekend at the Cheeca Lodge. After calling for a reservation (as suggested) and settling on a specific time, we arrived approximately 10 minutes early to find a near-empty restaurant. The hostess told us we would have a short wait... more

Stayed at Cheeca Lodge over New Year's and the week after. After a pitiful "Special 4 Course New Year's Dinner" experience(terrible, harried service and horrible filet/ quality of meat), we were hesitant to try Atlantics Edge. Should have listened to our gut feeling. Service was slow, slow, slow. My husband, son, and I all ordered the Kobe sirloin at $40... more

Atlantic's Edge is an American Express Platinum Card listed restaurant, so I had high expectations. I had my Platinum travel advisor make my reservation and made special notation this would be a birthday celebration for myself and a friend. We arrived a little early at a mostly empty restaurant and were told it would be a few minutes before our... more

My wife and I stayed at Cheeca Lodge this past weekend to celebrate her birthday. We do some research and read the reviews on Atlantic Edge. We decided to stay on property for our first night and made reservations for 8PM. We arrived at eight and were seated promptly at a beautiful beachside table with a great view of the... more

We stayed at Cheeca Lodge and I had read that Frommer's and Fodor's recommended this restaurant highly as one of the "Best in the Keys." Before traveling I do my research, but it was clear from my experience that the writers have not actually dined at this restaurant recently. I had the concierge at the hotel make the reservation for... more

Maybe not a 4 star, but a solid 3.75. We stayed at the Cheeca and debated eating here due to mixed reviews. However, we were tired on our day of arrival and decided to give it a go. We were very pleasantly surprised our salads were fine and we both enjoyed the grouper. A nice bottle of Pinot Noir and... more