This restaurant was closed when we were in Islamorada earlier this month so we were unable to sample its food, drink or ambience.
It was great when it was still open. But no longer. Seems the area is losing restaurants left and right these days.
We go to Bentley's every year that we are in Islamorada for a happy hour feast! The prices are terrific & the food outstanding! The drinks never disappoint either! I would highly recommend this spot for a happy hour treat!!
We have been eating at Bentleys for over 20 years, their food has always been outstanding. We took fresh fish there on a weekday and had it prepared two of our favorite ways: in the weeds and Bahamian. Both were salty and the sauces were completely different, the creamed spinach for the in the weeds was different also. We feel... More
This was my second time dinning at Bentley's. Like the first time, the interior of the place needs some work. It is very dark and the atmosphere is rather depressed, for lack of a better word. The food was truly disappointing. My stuffed yellowtail was small and bland. My son's scallops were so salty that he almost decided to leave... More
We really enjoyed eating at Bentleys! We brought our own lobster and they cooked it up delicious!! We were super pleased.
Been eating here for years, they have the best happy hour in town! The new chef is unbelievable, I typically get his special and haven't regretted it yet!!
WE HAVE BEEN EATING HERE FOR YEARS. The food is great and the people that work here are very friendly. You can join the bentley club and get a discount every time you eat here. The alligator and mussels are excellent. All tge crab dishes and fish has always been cooked perfect. We love the ice cream ball rolled in... More
If you own or manage Bentley's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing