If you are looking for a place to dine and not merely to eat in Islamorada, then Bentley's is the answer. It's as casual as you can get and yet the restaurant oozes with style. Menu is extensive and staff knows about each and every item. Our waiter, Jeffrey, guided us to a fabulous meal. If you are in Islamorada... more

signed in for a table. told of 5 pound fl lobster 90.00. told to hold it for us. sold it on us before we sat. more

I was craving crab legs, so my husband and I decided we would go out for dinner. We were going to go elsewhere, but read really good reviews about Bentley's so we decided to try it out. The outside of the building would give you the impression it is a bar atmosphere, but when you walk inside it was a... more

We managed to visit Bentleys three times during happy hour. Each time we enjoyed the wide variety of inexpensive and yummy appetizers. The happy hour is mostly for the appetizers and not for drinks. Service was very good from bartender, Chris. We had dinner one of those happy hour visits and was a bit disappointed with the "garlic, butter, caper... more

We have eaten over the years at Bentleys and previously had to wait up to a hour for a table. It is quieter now probably due to the burning down of the Checca Lodge but this just makes it much nicer to dine! The food and service was excellent and it is one restaurant everyone should visit at least once... more

We go to Bentleys every time we pass thru Islamorada. One time we gave them a bunch of fresh fish we caught and they cooked it up for us, four different ways. Luv this place more

During my first visit to Islamorada we decided to try this restaurant during our vacation because I read some good reviews about the place. First off, it has no view and is not on the water. If you are visiting the Keys there are plenty of restaurants to visit that have good food and are on the water. The food... more

Lucky to have visited several times on different vacations & each time the Diners in our group were very pleased! Whether it was for your Tuna Wasabi (the best) or a full shrimp dinner, the offerings were great. See you again in March '09! Thanks. Milford MI seafood hunters more

have the tuna steak w/a side of wasabi my wife has been getting the dolphin in the weeds for years.start with the coconut shrimp. john in ct. more