If that's an example of good New Jersey pizza then I feel sorry for Jersey folk. We are originally from Chicago. We want real cheese and plenty of toppings, both of which were missing on this pizza. We ordered a large pizza with extra cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion to go. If that's extra cheese, I'd hate to see what... more

What does it take to get good pizza in Florida? Bring New Jersey to Florida and Forgetaboutit!!! Excellent pizza and Italian dishes served inside or outside on their Jersey Boardwalk style porch and patio. more

Stopped at Boardwalk Pizza because I was told they had good cheese steaks and outside seating. I was traveling that day with a 6 month old puppy and a 7 week old kitten in a car I had borrowed from my brother in law. Left the car running with the pets and my wife in the car. Ordered my cheese... more

I have been living in the keys for a few years (a transplant from New England) and everywhere else I cannot find food that reminds me of home, well I sure found it here! I eat at this place on a VERY regular basis, the portions are huge, the staff is friendly. The quality of the ingredients will blow all... more

Boardwalk is a must stop if traveling threw the Islamorda area. Thier pizza and the service is the best in the upper keys. more

I stopped there on my way back to Islamorada after a day of snorkeling in Key Largo. The pizza was great and fairly priced. more

WOW.... we stopped in cause it looked like it could have great food & boy were we surprised! It was AMAZING almost everything on the menu was awesome....Its a small pizza/ italian/ the best philly steak sandwiches in florida! The service was awesome anytime you see the OWNER there all the time, its a good sign that the place is... more

You have to be skeptical about claims of NY style pizza in the Florida Keys but I have to admit, this place has superb pizza. The crust is thin and delicious and really makes it. We were informed that they have it flown in from NY! Small place but nice atmosphere and friendly staff. The Yuengling on tap doesn't hurt... more

Generally speaking, aside from a few places the Upper Keys are pretty much a food wasteland. So I was pleasantly surprised when I was prevailed upon to try Boardwalk Pizza. Now, it's not the greatest pie I've ever had, not by a long shot. But it is far better than any other pizza I've had in the Upper Keys, or... more