Went there for dinner tonight, though the meal was good, it is not a seafood place. Its really a Japanese Restaurant disguised as a local seafood place. The food was ok...not the best. If you are looking for Sushi.....dont miss this place. It really is off the beaten path and you may have to ask the locals for direction. more

It was recommended by the Blue Waters Motel otherwise I doubt we would have found it as it is located in an unsuspecting neighborhood. Their seafood is outstanding. It appears many locals go here. Service was very slow as the place was packed and they were shorthanded on wait staff. more

We loved the hidden nature of this place. The sushi was very nice and my husband's prime rib was good as well. The service was very friendly and the overall atmosphere was local, casual, in-part sports bar, sushi bar, with outdoor patio and bar tied together with eclectic seaside decor. Sounds crazy but it is a quaint spot for a... more

I love this place for the menu. It's hard to decide what to get. While the sushi lover could enjoy some of the best sushi ell rolls, other could just about get anything. We met some cool locals at the bar outside, even offered to buy us a drink ! We'll be back ! more

this was the worst shrimp we have ever had...the scampi was terrible and the booth was dirty. the waitress was very nice. more

We ate at castaways twice whilst in the keys in August. not an easy place to find but as they say on the T Shirt , well worth the search. Good food, friendly staff , nice atmosphere. Tried hogfish which was good. The honey buns are very tasty. more

The restaurant is a little tricky to find but it's worth looking for. We go there every year so I can have my annual lobster sandwich. I sure wish they would add the sandwich to the dinner menu so we could go there in the evenings, too. The food is just so wonderful. more

I loved the sushi. we ordered the boat for 2. there were 42 pieces of sushi. it was fresh and tasted great. the service was not to great, but we went on a very busy night. indoor and outdoor seating is available. there are large TV's in the restaurant. there is a bar, a raw bar, and regular dining tables. more

My family and I ate dinner at Castaway during our recent trip to Marathon. The food was great! The honey buns are delicious. We all loved them. My husband ordered the prime rib and I ordered the lobster. We decided to split our meals so we could have both of best worlds. I also ordered the California roll which was... more