Started with stone crabs as an appetizer. They weren't bad but cost $15 for two claws. Also ordered the smoke fish appetizer and some seafood stuffed potato skin appetizer. Both were terrible. No flavor. The chicken caesar wrap wasn't too bad. And for desert I had a fried slice of key lime pie. Nice idea, but it takes away from... more

Went with two kids and two adults, and enjoyed the indoor/outdoor, tiki style atmosphere. The service was very friendly, and everyone made us feel like "locals." Although not inexpensive, the food was tasty and well made. The conch ceviche was a special treat, chock full of meaty conch and enough for several people! My son wanted pasta and shrimp (without... more

I got to the restaurant at around 5:30, pretty early by my standards. The parking lot was packed, and I could only find one empty spot. Even with the packed parking lot, my party was seated within 10 minutes. I ordered the coconut shrimp, my favorite food. I ate coco shrimp 5 times in 1 week, and can honestly say... more

We took our fish that my husband and sons had caught the day before to have it prepared. For $12 per person, they prepared it and served it family style with 2 sides, plus bread and salad. The waitress checked with the chefs before taking our order so that the chef could recommend the best way to prepare the fish... more

I had the she-crab soup... very tasty. The atmosphere is wonderful.. just what you would expect from a restaurant in the keys. They are very busy, so go early or go late. this is an outdoor restaurant also, but it is right on the water and it always has a nice breeze blowing through it. more

Service was really bad. The waitress was more interested in the table full of young drinkers then our family of 4 and walked by our table MANY times without even looking. I had the scallop and steak special which was $30 and tasted like it came from Red Lobster. I understand waiting a little longer for our meals during the... more

My family and I ate at the Island Fish Company during our recent trip to Marathon. The atmosphere was great! The food was very good. They have a lot of different things to choose from on their menu. My husband ordered the filet mignon and said it was good. I ordered the Shrimp Diane and enjoyed it very much. It... more

tourist trap more

This restaurant was fantastic! The location was great, we overlooked the gulf, you could tie your boat up to the dock and have a great meal. Our waitress was very attentive and gave excellent service. My husband and I had yummy conch fritters, I had delicious fresh swordfish, and my husband had great stuffed shrimp. The atmosphere was open and... more