We had heard good things about the Butterfly Cafe (they were all true). Dined there for our first time this last Friday evening Nov 27th 2009. I had a fantastic filet, my fiancee had a superb grouper dish, each prepared perfectly. Best caesar salad I've had anywhere and the creme broulee was ummmm, so good. Head chef stopped by to... more

The butterfly cafe is absolutly fantastic. I had the grouper and my boyfriend had the steak, both were great! The flavor and presentation were both amazing. The chef even came out to greet us and assure that we were enjoying our meal. more

We had a fantastic meal at Butterfly Cafe last night. Everything was terrific from start to finish. Rebekah was our server and took great care of us. The food was delicious. I highly recommend dining here! more

Great food, great service, great atmosphere. A must if your are looking for a pleasurable dining experience in Marathon. more

We had dinner at Butterfly Cafe last night - wow! Amazing food and service...in fact, the best I have ever experienced in the Keys! We live in Miami and visit the Keys very often for weekend getaways. We have dined at Butterfly Cafe before, but the dinner and service last night seemed extraordinary. The Chef and Manager visited every table... more

Our previous visit to this restraunt we were reminded by almost all the employees to post a positive comment on trip advisor. Although the atmosphere and food could be noteworthy, the people working there are awful. I called to secure our reservation with a credit card as requested for the holidays. The cook answered the phone and when I tried... more

Went here for an anniversary dinner. Sitting on the deck was very romantic. Service was great! Conch chowder was very good though hubby's didn't have any conch! When he mentioned it they returned with a complementary order of crab cakes. Very good. The server Sharon was excellent! We'll definitely be back. more

GREAT GREAT GREAT FOOD!!!! I'm staying at the resort in which this restaurant is located at so I've had my share of different meals from this restaurant. I have not been unhappy with any meal. In fact, I have been utterly and unequivocally pleased with each and every bite. From the steak, to the pork chops, to the scallops n... more

There were so many positive reviews on TripAdvisor for this restaurant that we just had to try it - and we were not disappointed. The food was unbelievably delicious and the service we received, from Doug, Cheryl and especially Gabby, was excellent. To give some idea of the cost, the entrees ranged from around $12 to $44 so really you... more