Read reviews so we tried this place. Had a hard time finding it, the antipasta was just okay. The pizza was good. My husband dropped his wallet and we didn't know until we were back at the resort. I called as we drove back to ask if they found it, said no that we should check the parking lot. They... more

Great pizza! We just had a plain cheese pizza and it was really good! We ordered it to go, and the gentleman behind the bar that took my order was very kind. The place was very clean, and we're looking forward to trying more things off their menu! more

We decided on pizza one night during our week long stay at Duck Key. We found this establishment on the internet and we were not disappointed. Very nice family run restautant. Very good pizza. Check out the historic photos on the wall of the restaurant. We plan on going back when we come back down to the keys. more

After a hard day on the water (read "no big fish boated") we wanted something quick & easy. We Googled "Pizza" "Marathon" and decided on Upper Crust by the reviews on this site and others. We were very happy with our pick. The place was recently remodled and everything was clean inside. They had nice pics of old Marathon (30's-60's)... more

Do not judge a book by its cover in the Keys. The inside of Upper Crust Pizza is very nice in a homey way. The service was wonderful (of course, there was only one other talbe taken at 5pm). Our drinks were never lower than halfway before we were asked if we wanted a refill. The menu says that everything... more

Our motel recommended Upper Crust when we visited Marathon in 2005. We loved it - great pizza in a mom & pop place. It was a nice change-up to the seafodd we ate most of the week. We're going back to the Keys this summer and will definitely hit Upper Crust again! more

sometime you just eat too much of the good stuff and you need pizza. We searched on here for a suggestion and they were right. We called and ordered and went to pick up. They were friendly and the place was spotless and smelled amazing. We really enjoyed the pizza and even the homemade keylime pie and banna pie. If... more

The pizza and subs were decent. Had take out and ate at the pool. Better than chain pizza place. more

Stopped with my family and had some of the best pizza I have eaten. My son wanted to play a game that required me to take off my watch. I left it on the table. it was a diamond watch that was very sentimental. i called, they held it for me and I picked it up the next night. Very... more