I went to Herbie's as a kid on vacation with my parents, and back again when I was in my early 20's. It was definitely everything I remembered. It looks like a shack from the outside, but the conch fritters were great. I can say that I ate key lime pie everyday, and Herbie's had the best hands down. The... more

We ate here twice and enjoyed both meals. I had the cracked conch sandwich one night and the grilled fish one night. Both had lots of meat and were excellent. Key lime pie was very good too. I do have to admit that I've had better french fries. Wish I'd tried the sweet potato chips instead. Prices were reasonable and... more

We ate here while waiting on our rented house to be ready. It was recommended by the house owner, a local. The prices are a little high for the quality. We were thoroughly impressed with the fried oyster sandwich. Perfectly cooked. more

The prices are too high. The conch fritters were so so and the fish sand. over rated. The Key Lime Pie was very good. The service is quite spotty, indeed. Since it sits in an old weather beaten, sun drenched shak on the side of the overseas highway in Marathon it attracks a great variety of patrons - some of... more

The food is great. The place is very small and and very casual. Cash only no credit cards. If there are busy you could get porr service as the only have 1-2 people serving tables. Closed Sunday & Monday. For a casual local meal check it out. The crab stuffing is awesome. more

From the outside you will think,,, UHM,,, but do go in. It's not huge,,,,,,from the cleanliness of the picnic tables to the friendly service you will be happy. It is a true to life crab shack.The menu is huge and then there are tons of specials. My daughters wanted snow crab legs and they got a very large amount, that... more

Old-looking, weathered Keys style place. We both had Mahi nuggets and fries - YUM. Then we shared the Banana Herbie dessert thing. OMG. Bananas dunked in rum + vanilla ice cream + chocolate sauce + toasted almonds. Tasty. Good value for amount of food, friendly old gals as servers. You can tell it's a local eatery but bunches of tourists... more

Herbie's was OK. I do not think that I would go back but, I was not unhappy with the experience. The servers were so nice- they tried really hard. The food was just OK. The fried grouper sandwich was really good. The other food, the crab cakes and the conch fritters were just OK. I was not unhappy but, would... more

The choices in Marathon are limited, but, we probably wouldn't return to Herbies. more