After reading the reviews, this restaurant seemed like a good selection. It is a quaint restaurant with a large outdoor seating area. We were greeted immediately at the door and taken to a seat by the water. However that's the last service we received. We waited and waited at our table. Other tables were served. After waiting twenty minutes, we... more

We were looking for a place to have lunch on the water, and after reading some of the reviews, we decided to give Bonefish Willy's a try. We were greated by the hostess who was sitting in front of the restaurant right outside the door smoking a cigarette, she snuffed it out and showed us around back to a spot... more

We both enjoyed the meal here. We had excellent service and the food - we are not too adventurous so we both had shrimp-was the best we found in Melbourne. The evening was definately a 10. more

Truly a great dining experience! more

This laid back and quaint restaurant was a real treat. The menu featured some fantastic fish. Be warned, the bread is so good here, if you crave buttery garlic toasted warm bread, you'll never ever have room for dessert. We're going to be back in the area in January, and this will be one of our first culinary stops. more

You know, most ppl here and on another foodie message board generally rave about this place. With that in mind, I had high expectations for dinner there. Simply, I, nor the other 3 adults and 2 kids were not disappointed. We arrived for dinner w/out reservations on Friday around 7pm. I knew that coulda been an issue, but it wasn't... more

This place is North of Eau Gallie on Pineapple. In kind of a residential area. The place looks like it used to be an old home. Dont be fooled. Maybe part of the charm?? We were greeted by a large black cat at the entrance. I guess if I were a cat this is where I would hang out to.... more

The locals recommended Bonefish Willy's to us and boy were we happy. We are a family of 4 with two teen's and they really loved the food and the atmosphere, Very key west like.. Love the art work and the plates they used to serve the food looked so cool and vintage. The service was A+++++ most importantly...the food ...good... more

Aside from the cool overlook onto the Indian River, the polite waiters, and the uniquely decorated atmosphere, Bonefish Willys was far from the second best restraunt in Melbourne, a town I've lived in for over 10 years. Their New York Strip was rather bland and tough and the chicken in the ceasar salad had no grill marks on it, as... more