Average food in an average setting. They need to learn about garlic, basil and oregano if they're going to call themselves an Italian restaurant. The food was bland and nothing I couldn't have made myself. Prices are high for average food in a strip mall setting. I'm no fan of chain restaurants but I think the Olive Garden does it... more

Great little restaurant with excellent service and good food. Here is a secret: Though it isn't on the menu (you have to ask for it!), they have probably the best burger in Tallahassee and the fries are perfect! Yes, Anthony's!! more

My boyfriend and I went to Anthony's a few weeks ago and were more then pleased by the excellent service and delicious food. All meals come with salads with dressings made in house. I must say one of the best house salads I've ever had. My boyfriend ordered grouper and I ordered chicken marsala, both were delicious. *The espresso pie... more

Been once but loved the chicken fettacinni alfredo. Service was good. We sat at the table closest to the entrance, which wasn't that great. But the rest of the place looked cozy. On my list to revisit. more

ok-snobby atmosphere, I wouldn't go back. more

Since this restaurant was rated 3rd in Tallahasse I figured it would be worth the effort. It wasn't. Not sure what that means for those poor establishments rated lower. I went early one Sunday evening, so the place was only moderately busy. The waiter took ever so long to show up, but he finally took a cocktail order. It came... more

We visited Antony's last week after asking locals where to go to get great food at a decent price. We were greeted warmly at the door by the owner, who showed us to a seat with a window view. As I understand it, they have a new chef, Todd, who has created many new dishes. The food was wonderful (veal... more

We went to this restaurant because of the high marks from this forum, but we were very disappointed. The entrees are very middle of the road, all entrees come with a vermicelli pasta which is extremely bland and very inexpensive to serve. However, the prices are quite high. We came to the conclusion that we would have enjoyed a much... more

My husband and I spent Labor Day weekend in Tallahassee and visited Anthony's on Saturday night. Being from Ft. Lauderdale, we don't dine in restaurants that are this charming and relaxed. The service was incredible, so professional and warm. We were there for almost 2 hours! We felt like we got our money's worth for the expense and had a... more