I thought it was a little pricey for what we got $16 for a scallop/clam strip platter which would be okay if it were delicious and plentiful. However, the scallops were tiny and the clam strips rubbery and teeny-tiny. It did not come with a salad. The fries and corn nuggets (2) were good. We sat outside and the workers... more

When I travel, I consider myself successful if I'm able to find that hole-in-the-wall place that has great local food. Barnacle Bill's fit the bill for me. Now some may argue with the hole-in-wall status that I've given it, but I think it's important to set expectations properly if I'm giving you a review. The decor is dated, the tables... more

I found Barnacle Bill's to be a very interesting establishment! With a fishy & nautical decor: it's in an old warehouse, where the lighting is just plain bad annoying fluorescent lights. The food was amazingly well prepared, fresh and plentiful, and also relatively inexpensive for what you get: I've eaten far worse at many a 5 star restaurant, and the... more

Years ago we loved getting steamed oysters at Barnacle Bills. No more! Feeling nostalgic, we went there for my birthday. All the seafood was overcooked and rubbery. Notified the managment. Didn't even respond. Never will go back again. more

Great happy hour specials! Good food! more

Good place for cheap oysters, and pitchers of beer. more

Awesome seafood, mostly FRESH from FLORIDA, all cooked out where you can see it done expertly by experienced cooks: not chefs. Which knocks at least $10 off the price tags per plate. My husband and I take our 3 small children there at least weekly and it costs around $60 for everything including a pitcher or two, and a couple... more

The food was great. The prices are amazing. The atmosphere was good other than we had a little trouble with the waiters. One waiters constant flirting made me and my husband uncomfortable. I was embarrased and appalled.On several occasions the waiter called me Babe or Hun Or Darling right in front of my husband. Also with a wink he kept... more

Barnacle Bill's is our favorite casual dining spot in Tallahassee. I don't even like salmon but I adore their smoked salmon dip appetizer. If you are really hungry, their Monster Seafood Bucket is absolutely wonderful. The atmosphere is downhome, no fancy candles or plasma TVs, but if you want good seafood at a reasonable price, you need to give it... more