This place is wonderful!!! We arrived early for dinner and were the first to be seated in the dining room. We were attended to by a fun waiter, whose name escapes me now. He told us about the specials, explained things I didn't understand and was sweet to our daughter. We chose Mushroom Neptune as an appetizer...yummy! My husband ordered... more

Had dinner here many, many times and have never been disappointed. Monday night was the lamb chop special that is so good falling off the bone tender. 5 in the party had a mix of seafood and beef and everybody left fat and happy. Service with a smile, fully stocked bar and wine list and extremely well prepared food. Whats... more

Planning a trip to Key Largo, FL to get away from the whole work and school life, my friends and myself decided to go out to a nice restaurant. We went to the Old Tavernier on May 5th, 2009. My server Robert was one of the best server we had. The menu selection was small and the food was overpriced,... more

After we had eaten burgers and fried food for 1½ week we found this very nice and cosy restaurant where the people serving actually knew how to serve guests. The food was great and our 2 year old eat almost all of her pasta with seafood, which is a very rare happening. The prices are on the high side, but... more

Old Tavernier has pretty good food but its very expensive at times and the service is ify but overall good restuarant because i live write by it lol more

Our party of three were lucky enough to rent a house within walking distance of the Old Tavernier Restaurant in June 2007. We were out fishing all day and ended up eating there on about 12 nights of our stay. That may seem extravagant but the food was so good we kept coming back. We visit this area for the... more

We could not find a restaurant on a quiet week in Key Largo, they were generally either closed or lacked atmosphere. Luckily we ended up at the Old Tavernier. It was like a step back in time but with great food and good service. more