My husband and I enjoyed our dinner at Old Tavernier. I had the yellow fin special and my husband had the prime rib - both meals were excellent. The service at the restaurant was fantastic, and the server was very knowledgeable. more

Of all the meals I had in the Keys, this one was the biggest disappointment. The food was "just ok" ...not bad. But for the price, I had most other meals twice as exciting for half as much. I'd skip this one, and enjoy some less expensive fare. more

The service was fantastic. My husband's order was not correct, but it didn't matter. He loved what he was served. As soon as our waiter realized there was an error, he went WAY out of his way to make us happy (but we weren't UNhappy with the mistake). more

Great food and athmosphere a bit pricey but its a fncy retraunt so you would expect that great food and service. more

Fabulous for the entire family.....from the appetizers to the salads, main courses and dessert, we were blown away. All four of us had something different (Prime Rib, Yellowtail Snapper Almondine, Shrimp Scampi and a Pasta with many types of fish and a luscious gorgonzola sauce), and each was better than the next. The service was great, and we were well... more

This place is wonderful!!! We arrived early for dinner and were the first to be seated in the dining room. We were attended to by a fun waiter, whose name escapes me now. He told us about the specials, explained things I didn't understand and was sweet to our daughter. We chose Mushroom Neptune as an appetizer...yummy! My husband ordered... more

Had dinner here many, many times and have never been disappointed. Monday night was the lamb chop special that is so good falling off the bone tender. 5 in the party had a mix of seafood and beef and everybody left fat and happy. Service with a smile, fully stocked bar and wine list and extremely well prepared food. Whats... more

Planning a trip to Key Largo, FL to get away from the whole work and school life, my friends and myself decided to go out to a nice restaurant. We went to the Old Tavernier on May 5th, 2009. My server Robert was one of the best server we had. The menu selection was small and the food was overpriced,... more

After we had eaten burgers and fried food for 1½ week we found this very nice and cosy restaurant where the people serving actually knew how to serve guests. The food was great and our 2 year old eat almost all of her pasta with seafood, which is a very rare happening. The prices are on the high side, but... more