We live in Evanston and have eaten at almost every restaurant in the area, including Pete Miller's. Last night was our first time at Davis Street Fishmarket. Sadly, it will be our only dinner there. The food was good (not great) but the service, the ambience, and the overall experience left a lot to be desired. Our drinks arrived and... more

We were exhausted and it was late at night and was one of the few restaurants open. My husband, daughter and I shared peel and eat shrimp, crab cake salad and seafood ettouffee. While a bit on the expensive side, it was all excellent. I would eat here again. more

As an added plus we went on the King Crab Leg special. I was told by the waitress there were no king crabs so I ordered something else, only 30 minutes later to see others eating crab legs. I went with a party of 4 and everyone regretted it more

The original owner of the Fishmarket - Steve Prescott -is probably rolling in his grave - God bless him.. He started a simple, service oriented restaurant and it's turned into a place where the waiters do not understand the diners' English and the food is lukewarm and just not very good. What a shame for a place that was magnificent... more

After reading some unfavorable reviews I headed into the Davis Street Fish Market with some anxiety. My husband, parents, children, and I were all dining together and I needed things to go smoothly. They most certainly did. The dining room is interesting and comfortable; the fishtank in the center of the space is very cool. Our server took good care... more

Fresh fish prepared to your liking (I love the grilled whitefish when it's available). Delicious oysters and friendly atmosphere (not too stuffy). more

Great food. Book reservation on opentable.com! more

We've eaten there a few times this summer and been really pleased with out dinners each time. For years we had only mixed feelings about going there but they seem to have really made improvements to the menu and staff and it has paid off. There are always some interesting fish choices outside the usual but all we've sampled have... more

Has gone downhill recently. Miss the atmosphere from before the remodel - all the character is gone now. more