I read the other reviews on this restaurant and I honestly don't really agree. I thought the service was poor for this level of establishment. Our server was either missing when we wanted him, or hovering when we did not. I am not a fish eater but did quite enjoy the food I ordered. The other 3 people in my... more

Some of the best seafood and service you're going to get. more

I sat at the bar in the Naperville store and had a terrific time. The food was excellent, and the specially-priced three course meal was a steal. And the serving person was top-notch. more

We tried Catch 35 for the first time and had an awesome time...We were a little early for our reservations but they sat as at a really nice table...Our waiter was great and knew about everything on the menu. There was a big variety of items on the menu...The crab bisque soup was really good...My husband said his steak was... more

went there for easter brunch ... never again will I set foot into this restaurant. made reservations, they called and confirmed. got there and the food looked like it had been laying there since 11 am. most of the hot pans were cold. they were putting new heat cans out but it was too late to save this crap. $30... more

This is my favorite place to go for special occasions... The lobster here is to die for. It will literally just melt in your mouth, and it is always sweet and tender. I can't even eat lobster anywhere else because other restaurants always overcook it till it's rubbery and gross. The service tries very hard, too hard sometimes. The last... more

I would love to be able to eat here as it is so close to my house, but the menu is so limited, there is nothing I would want to order. Please diversify! more

We just got home from dinner at Catch35 and I felt I had to write a review to reward them for such a great dinner. They have oysters for 1/2 price from 4:00-6:00, and gave us the special price even though we didn't arrive until 10 minutes after 6:00pm. Our waiter was superb and the wait staff was always there... more

I've been wanting to try Catch 35 for several years and finally had an opportunity last Friday night. The overall atmosphere is nice---it has a clean, minimalist decor---the tables were comfortable, and the wait staff is friendly. However, our dinners were rather bland. I had the parmesan encrusted Lake Superior white fish and my friend had the crab-encrusted tilapia. Though... more