Well, my title sort of sums up this place. They are located near the Ocean Edge Resort in Brewster and delivered right to the resort. We ordered the pizza and it was at our door in about 15 minutes! Super, lightning fast delivery if you ask me! The pizza itself was pretty good. We had a large which seemed quite... more

I've been ordering from Brewster Pizza since they've been open. NEVER have I ever had a problem with my order. I appreciate their prompt service and consistantly good food. As in any restuarant, one must explain how they want their meal prepared, every person prepares an item differently therefore I feel the other reviews unfair. I personally have worked in... more

I have to concur with the reviewer who said customer service was lacking (though I disagree that a sub means it's cold). Anyway, the women at the register run hot and cold...sometimes they're pleasant and other times their not. They seem to get frustrated easily if you don't order "correctly" (quick enough, clearly enough, etc). That said, I do like... more

when a restaurant employee states that their best pizza is a plain cheese you have to know how simple and boring the place is. When asked what was their second best and the answer was pepperoni. Clearly a place that has no pride or creativity. more

As a resident of Brewster for over 15 years, I've been to Brewster Pizza House a number of times over the years, although not regularly. I prefer Italian style pizza and theres is more Greek. I also prefer cold subs, rather than their toasted grinders, so I always make a point of ordering a "sub" when I go there. Which... more