We have been going to El Guapo's since the beginning of last summer and have always had a good time. The place is clean. Staff is friendly. Seating is limited but something usually opens up pretty quickly as its mainly takeout. Love the Carne Asada Burrito and the Steak with Roasted Poblanos. Lots of Vegetarian Options (my girlfriend) too. Only... more

I visited El Guapos this evening with my family looking for some affordable but tasty mexican food and I'd heard some great things about the place from friends. My friends were on the money. The food was delicious and for my family of four, it only cost around $30 for us to be more than full. I had a smothered... more

We ate outside, instead of the rather tiny and boring inside. I would imagine this food also travels well. Prices are reasonable and the selection very nice. I ordered the fish tacos - because I was not tired of seafood yet. They were ok but I would not order them again. The fish was completely lost in the double flour... more

If you want Mexican, don't come here! i'm stumped as to why this restaurant (if you can call it that) is rated so highly!! It is basically an overpriced take-out joint. Everything is extra...you want chips and salsa? $6. I had a chicken cheese quesedilla, which was $7...it was made up of a white flour tortilla grilled, with jack cheese... more

Cute little location off the side of the bike trail but the food was not for me. The prices were to high for the food we were served. The food was too greasy. El Guapo's is overrated. Lucky to have that location but needs to improve there food. more

I reside in Brewster and have often eaten at El Guapo's when I just don't feel like cooking. It's a small restaurant, very limited seating (except when the weather is nice) and usually there is fast service, except when the staff just doesn't respond. The pricing is moderate, except it will add up. The food is okay, often extra greasy... more

Go there often and recently while on the Rail Trail Everything is good, esp. the guac. and chips. more

We've been visiting El Guapo's since it opened and have never had a bad experience! the food is always fresh and delicious, the staff is friendly, and the prices are very reasonable. the food is simple and refreshingly NOT over-thought. we love the enchiladas and the costa rican burrito. we're thrilled with the new spot but please! bring back the... more

We stopped here for lunch while riding on the rail trail and it was delicious! It's a very casual place with a few tables inside and picnic tables outside. But it's far tastier than your usual casual fare. My husband ordered the fish tacos and I ordered the chicken fajitas. Both we fabulous. The salad fixings were fresh and lots... more