I've always loved Smalleys BBQ. The food is excellent and always has unique flavor. The different rums and cocktails are fun to play around with. I would like to see some new menu items now that they've been open awhile though. They have added a game room upstairs. Shuffle board (woo hoo!), 2 dart boards, foose ball, duck hunter and... more

We live in downtown Stillwater, and up until tonight enjoyed going to Smalley's. Beer is cheap and they have a "bean bag" room. The staff there is completely incompetent and after being in the back bar area for about an hour, we were asked to leave and accused of entering the bean bag area without permission. They just recently got... more

We tryed this for a more causal dinner, attached to a bar area, noise from the bar wasn't that loud, food was mostly on the BBQ flavor . Large portions. fun atmosphere. more

The service was great,however I found the food was mediocre. The meat was over smoked and over spiced. As a pitmaster I know you have to be able enhance the flavor of the meat by seasoning and smoking it,however you still have to be able to taste the meat after the smoking process. We went there to celebrate our aniversary... more

Specifically stopped in Stillwater for lunch at Smalley's. The restaurant looked closed from the front of the building but noticed the back area open. We were seated on the back patio and almost left after looking around. It was dirty, bleak, and extremely unappetizing. Watching the cooks and waitstaff come in and out of a dirty, dirty, back door made... more

My wife and I visited Smalley's Saturday evening. We had wanted to visit for some time after seeing them open. After reading all of the negative reviews we almost didn't go. I'm glad we did, although my wife and I reached different conclusions. First, we had excellent service. Most of the recent reviews seem to knock the service, but the... more

We had been to the restaurant after it had first opened and had a very disappointing experience and I said I would'nt go back. Well we decided to try the happy hour in the bar Friday night because they told me when I called we could sit on the back patio. Their website lists all these drinks and appetizers and... more

The atmosphere was very loud and cramped seating. The wait staff was overly casual in dress and very unresponsive to giving good service. Their menus needed updating, ours were very worn and the plastic overlay was very dirty. more

I have been to Smalley's twice....the first time everything was great. The wait staff was entertaining and knowledgeable, the food and drinks were great. It was good all around. Because of the great first experience I had I decided to go to Smalley's for my birthday on 4/8/09 with five great friends. The waitress seemed to be having a bad... more