Great midtown location, Washington St location.X-tra large slices, but owner son is a cop so there is always double parking there. Food is very good. Wine and beer available.
We had heard from several people about how good and huge the pizza slices are. The slices are very big but more importantly taste very good. Nice amount of cheese, delicious home-made sauce and crust was just right. Prices are very reasonable. Will definitely go there again.
Someone asked me where my favorite pizza was. When I told them it was Benny Tudino's, they asked if I wanted to go there for dinner. Even though I was two hours away in Connecticut, I thought about it because the pizza is that good. The staff is wonderfully curt -- none of this "every customer is a special gem"... More
We were lucky to hit Benny Tudino's on the night of his 45th anniversary in business.. A big celebration. Free slices for everyone. Plus a piece of anniversary cake. Nice people. Benny was on hand talking to everybody. Music going, lights flashing outside. You felt very welcome. We had starters and dinners for four. We were all very pleased.. The... More
Food is your typical pizzeria, slices are huge. Staff is attentive. Food was served quickly and the price is good.
waitress was great, food came so quick we had the antipasto [$8] tiny at the same time as the pizza, and ordered garlic bread with cheese. My slice i ordered ham on it, didn't know it would be large squared of cold cuts. The brocolli slice was better. Pizza besides the ham was ok , i would not rate as... More
Benny's was our first stop on our recent visit to NYC. We stayed in Hoboken and wanted something walkable. Benny was in when we arrived and the food was tasty, delivered quickly and very reasonably priced. Great value and good service with a good atmosphere, thanks
Travelled to NYC for Labour Day weekend with family, stayed in Weehauken. Ordered from Benny Tudinos 3 nights in a row. Fantastic everything! Wings were amazing, pasta dishes are huge and the pizza is OMG. Can't wait to go back.
Warning: Native to the area who has not been in the area for some time. The following review may be dramatically skewed due to a pure sense of longing for non-chain or mass produced pizza that I grew up with in the north place of pizza by the slice (at least to me) Benny's has been around for a long... More
Stopped here for lunch and had a great time. Our server, Cassandra was the best; she sat down with us to explain the vast menu, After our choice of the large, and I mean LARGE, pizza along with wings and a side salad for Mom-Mom who doesn't do wings we had some wonderful crusty bread while waiting. When the side... More
If you own or manage Benny Tudino's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing