We used to frequent this restaurant and their food/service was excellent. After they opened the bar next door - they cut corners at Settler's with food. They cut down on the amount and the quality. (i.e., used to buy a sandwich that came with a cup of soup and french fries - they they cut down and only gave you... more

This place empties one nearly depleted bottle into another. The ketchup in the bottle on your table may be over ten years old. Also, they refuse to throw out meat that has gone bad. I thought I was going to have to go to the hospital after eating their Greek Chicken Salad several weeks ago. more

Great food, for a good price more

If it weren't for the quality of food, the low price and the friendly service, I wouldn't eat here. As it is, Batavia seems to be on our way there, or else on our way back, from wherever we are going to or coming from when we drive through Buffalo. Strange that! It is but five minutes off the I-90,... more