I made reservations here two weeks before we arrived by leaving a message and there was no trouble; they had them andf seated us right away. The food was great; one of the best dinners we had on our 10 days trip through New England. It was moderate to expensive but had good food, good wine and good waiters. more

Great Italian food with great atmosphere. We own a BandB(thehaydencreekinn.com) near Cooperstown and send a lot of people here every summer and they all love it. Great portions, a definite bang for your buck. more

We were recommended to try this establishment by the innkeeper where we were staying. We are a picky italian family from brooklyn so we know our italian food. Nicolettas gave generous portions of well prepared food for a very reasonable price. The dining room is elegant and comfortable and the abiance is wonderful. The young woman who took care of... more

I ordered the veal saltimboca and it was like eating a stick of butter with a little pasta. I dont remember tasting anything and I left sick. My salad was very good though. My friend ate the spagetti and it was cheap and looked alot better than what I ate. Keep it really simple and you will be fine here.... more

Nicoletta's is the local equivalent of Italian comfort food - all the standards well prepared - with an atmosphere and service to match. But anyone that has spent any time in Cooperstown - ie. more than a few nights, knows that the restaurants to go to are Alex & Ika's (get anything), Hoffman's Lane Bistro (the Hanger Steak), the Hawkeye... more

We were delighted to find our way into Nicoletta's for a Labor Day Saturday night. The staff was accommodating and welcoming - lovely warm hostess and efficient wait staff. We enjoyed the cuisine - great Parmigiana. Good value - I recommend highly. more

Just got back from lovely Cooperstown. My husband who loves to cook, wanted Italian for dinner. Walked into Nicoletta's not sure how the food was going to be ( we're from L.I.) we know good Italian food!. Well, it was outstanding. We also went back the next night. Food, service...probably best Italian food I have ever had. Definaltley "Little Italy"... more

As residents of Cooperstown, this is our favorite place to take out of town guests, or to spend a warm summer evening. The food has always been top quality, properly prepared and served. As we are retirees, we are concerned about value as well as quality, and there is no better choice than Nicolleta's. Ther are many pasta choices for... more

My wife and I visited Cooperstown in May our very first visit. Went mainly to see the Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, before school let out and therefore before the crowds. We were attracted by the menu outside the restaurant, went in, were given a nice table, food, drink, service and ambiance were all first-rate! We liked it so... more