My wife and I have eaten at the Hilltop Inn many times.. We both enjoy the experience each time we go. We send our guests from the B and B there all the time. They all come back with the same experience., If you are in the Elmira area, I would strongly recommend The Hilltop Inn.. enjoy the beautiful view... more

This was the first time we had visited the Hill Top and although we were impressed with the view, we can only say that the food was "ok". There was a wedding taking place along with a large dinner party. It was awkward walking through the wedding reception area (the wedding hadn't started yet) as well as the larger dinner... more

Easy to find right off the expressway and up the hill on Jerusalem Hill Road. Our nine person party, mostly strangers to the area, enjoyed a moderately priced meal and compared the food favorably to the nicest restaurants they had been to anywhere. more

While I live in Rochester, I travel for many programs in the Elmira area and to meet with Doctors on a regular basis. I have been to Hill Top six times in the last year alone as that is one of the only places the doctors wish to go to. I have had nothing but excellent meals and service and... more

I have eaten at the Hill Top several times in the last year and each time I become more & more impressed. The food is exceptional. I have always found the servers quite friendly, personable & accomodating. I have never had an incident when I've had to wait an unreasonable amount of time to be served and my dinner has... more

We went to visit my mother in Elmira for one night in August. We were planning to attend a family reunion in Pennsylvania the next day and wanted to have a special dinner that night. It was a beautiful evening and the view was spectacular. Service was oh so slow and the wait for our meals to arrive was excrutiating.... more

Every time we go to Hill Top we get cold food. 3 out of 8 times we have had cold steak and potatos. A group of Seniors went to Hill Top for there Senior Prom dinner and had the most TERRIBLE service ever. Only 1/2 of the kids got served there food and that was cold. After being there for... more

My fiance and I had been shopping for a place for our wedding for about four months when my future sister-in-law had her wedding up there at the hilltop. It was spectacular! Everything seemed to run like clockwork. The staff was friendly and attentive, the food was great and well presented and the view ... simply gorgeous! We asked my... more

I've been to the Hill Top Inn on many occasions and I have never experienced better service, food, or view than what I did at Hill Top Inn. The people there make you feel like you are having a nice dinner at home without the worries of doing anything. Everyone who works there are well-mannered and seem intelligent. The food... more