if you are anywhere's in the vicinity you MUST eat here! quaint, quite, modern, and AMAZING FOOD!! short menu, great wine list, and the atmosphere is great!! more

Madder Lake is a quaint little restaurant on Seneca Lake in Geneva. We had lunch there and were extremely pleased with the food and service...it was awesome. We loved the atmosphere and the decor. Laura was very helpful with our menu selections and choice of wines. We would highly recommend Madder Lake to anyone traveling in the Finger Lakes. Their... more

Our favorite restaurant in the Finger Lakes! The food is terrific with a great wine list of both local and international wines. The menu emphasizes dishes using local ingredients that are creatively prepared, delicious, and always exceptional. The decor is warm with bold colors and art from local artists. The staff is friendly and the service is excellent. We highly... more

My visit to Madder Lake was a wonderful experience. The atmosphere, food and wine was all great. The choice is somewhat limited, but everything I and my family had was soooo good. Also, it was nice to have Finger Lakes wines with the meal! more

My boyfriend and I are from Philadelphia and were just in Geneva for a night and we were looking for a nice but affordable place for a birthday/celebratory dinner. We saw Madderlake's menu online and were intrigued. The ambience was impressive compared to other places in Geneva. The food was fresh and flavorful. Would recommend this place to anyone who... more

Here is a perfect example of quality local ingredients transforming a dining experience into something unforgettable. Madderlake doesn't try to hard or venture into over-the-top territory. Simple, ripe and fresh food cooked perfectly-why serve anything BUT? This place has their priorities straight! We were lucky enough to be waited on by one of the owners of the restaurant who had... more

My fiance and I were staying in Geneva and decided to go to a place that serves up local vegetables and eclectic fare. Madderlake's menu was posted online and looked like it would be worth visiting. The ambiance is very simple, no frills, which was fine. The service was attentive and friendly. We love lamb on Easter and opted for... more

My husband and I enjoyed our anniversary dinner at Madderlake Cafe. My husband used to work as a chef...so we have fairly high expectations when it comes to food (it doesn't have to be fancy - just well prepared). Overall, we had a good experience at Madderlake. We started with a fried calamari, shrimp and scallop appetizer - which was... more

Glad we looked at TripAdvisor. Reviews were right on target - Good food;excellent service;great prices on wine;will go back again when visiting Geneva/Finger Lakes. more