As a visitor to Shelter Island, I have seen this place for the past 10 yrs and decided to finally try it. We walked in at 445pm and only 1 couple were in the establshment. We were greeted and sat immediatly. So far, so good. After a few minutes, the server (ashley) asked us what to drink and we ordered... more

This is a very convenient location near the ferry to Shelter Island. It's also very scenic from the outdoor dining area. The schedule (open year round) is a plus too. If you eat here, stick with quesadillas and other simple food. We ate fish one night and it was waaay off. The steak was a day old too. The salads... more

Best thing was the view of the ferries coming and going. Our chowder, salads, and baked stuffed shrimp were incredibly ordinary. The shrimb was advertised as having a scampi sauce. There was no sauce, just some melted butter on the bottom of the plate. It wasn't BAD, but it was just very ordinary. The mixed vegetables on my plated looked... more

This is a good and decent little restaurant. It's nothing fancy and a great lunch choice. The service is outstanding, and the outdoor seating has a fantastic view of the harbor and Shelter Island. The food is pretty good. I ordered the cajun chicken sandwich and I've definitely had better chicken sandwiches before. But it really wasn't bad. The prices... more

I just had to respond the to review "Stay Away from this Horrible "Dining" Experience!." He should go to the Frisky Oyster. That'd leave a table open for me at the Chowder Pot where I could overlook the marina while enjoying the friendly wait staff and delicious food. more

I cannot understand how the Chowder Pot Pub could possibly be rated the #1 restaurant in Greenport by people who have actually dined there. Please note that this is not the only review posting a 1-star rating. If you have the least bit of sophistication in your dining expectations or do not like to wildly overpay for your meals, read... more

Great for drinks at the outside bar. Beautiful view of Bay. Bartender Adria was very nice and extremely friendly. Ask for her Mojito its one of the best. more

The best view of the Shelter Island Ferry and the Peconic Bay!. Most relaxing place to grab a drink and just chill out in summer on the deck or in the cozy pub on a rainy noreaster day in the fall. Great seafood and fantastic prime rib on Fri. and Sat. nights. some high end dishes but also great comfort... more

This is where I go for comfort....... Although I live 2 hours from this Pub, it is by far my favorite place. I'm a little long Island girl and you wont find chowder as good as this anywhere else. Many restuarants attempt to make the "best" New England clam chowder and they do it right! It is located in the... more