We chose this restaurant for our Valentine's Day dinner based upon local recommendations. As others have noted the hostess was cold and surly. She managed to give you the impression that she was annoyed at having to deal with you. We had looked at their menu on line and were surprised when the menu we were given was a "Special... more

My goodness! It's hard to imagine that the other reviewers were eating at the same restaurant that I've loved for over 15 years. To my thinking, MacDuff's is a unique treasure among Jamestown, NY dining. Promoting themselves as an intimate restaurant serving European Style Cuisine (not French...see their website), Gary and Donna Templin have the utmost repsect for the food... more

I must second many of Guiness' opinions on MacDuff's. I have eaten there many times and feel annoyed every time the woman comes to recite the menu without prices. She really gives you the impression that if you aren't polite enough or don't choose quickly enough, she won't ALLOW you to eat there. And I wonder if the prices vary... more

MacDuff's was recommended to us as a French style restaurant that offered wonderful wine pairing. We were sadly mislead. We dine out quite often and have had our run ins with a bad appetizer, salad or entree but I have never been so disappointed with a entire meal. First, I would like to point out that MacDuff's is not a... more