Back on the North Fork for summer and went to Pepi's. As soon as we walked in we noticed the place had been nicely repainted but it had no energy. Pepi was gone, the hostess was watching TV. I asked if Pepi had sold the place and was told they opened a new restaurant but it was still the same... more

Recently returned from Pepi's this past Sunday night and the food was far below average, the sauce tasted straight out of a jar and I have to say that the Veal Parm. was one of the worst I have ever tasted, no wonder Restaurant.com gives out a $15.00 discount. Our meal came out within 6 minutes of ordering kinda strange... more

Pepis is average at best but overpriced for what you are served, 21$ for Veal Parm with some spagehtti underneath. The menu is straightfoward American Italian, lots of red sauce. The food has no distinction. Service is casual-why go-maybe to sit on the deck over the water. The indoor section is small and lack luster. I see no reason to... more

outside and inside eating areas! i love this place! it is right on the dock! but watch out u dont get to drunk and fall into the water... hehehe more

My wife and I recently moved to Southold and, having eaten at many restaurants on the North and South Forks, I believe Pepi's to be one of the best around. It has FANTASTIC Veal and Chicken Parm (believe it or not, it rivals La Parm in Southampton!) We have been totally blown away by the service, the food, and the... more

My wife and I have dinner out every week.on eastern Long Island. We have eaten from Montauk to Westhampton and I must say that Pepi's was the worst dining experience we had all summer. The menu was nothng special. A local pizza shop menu has a better variety. To start, the focaccia they put on the table was ice cold... more