We had an excellent dinner here and would be very happy to recommend it to other travellers. It was very good food with friendly staff and a nice ambience. Definitely worth a visit.
The staff was friendly and the service was fast. I got the fish tacos since the waitress said the fish was flounder and that it was caught that day. It did not taste fresh. My wife got shrimp tacos and said it was excellent. The meal was overpriced for what we got.
Casual, fresh seafood spot. Everything was pretty average. Fresh grilled fish was good but the hamburg was served on a brioche bun. An odd choice for a burger bun, too sweet and rich. Service was ok. Once was enough and even though options were limited we doubled up on other spots.
Always have a great dinner every time we come in. The service is also excellent. Every time we are in Buxton we eat here!
As we expected, finding an abundant selection of restaurants on Cape Hatteras was not going to happen. However, Rusty's was a better than decent place for dinner. Service was efficient, and the food was fresh and well prepared. It appeared that some of the locals frequent this restaurant, so it can't be all bad. Everything from the salads to the... More
Quick service with reasonable prices. Restaurant serves sandwiches to dinners. Must be popular with the locals because it was busy the whole time we were there.
Tired of typical seashore food...Then try Rusty's. High quality food, prepared very well and served by friendly staff. It was recommended by a friend who's in the food service biz, and he was right. Not a place for the kids but great for us grown ups who appreciate good food.
Good service, tropical settings. Great jambalaya and great dessert. The coffee was nice and strong. Friendly service.
My Favorite Restaurant On Hatteras Island. I'd Rather Pay A Little More & Get Really Good Food. Fried Shrimp Is Best I've Had Anywhere. The Sauce On The Beef Medallions Was Very Good.
If you own or manage Rusty's Surf & Turf, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing