The inside of Colosseo is simply beautiful. The martini bar is very inviting. I'm not one much for $11 martinis, but that place made me want to belly up to the bar and order up a "Take Her Home" which incorporates Poprocks! As far as the food goes...very tasty. It may sound odd to point out something so small, but... more

Went for the first time tonight with a friend. Wanted drinks and dinner. The food was great, atmosphere was awesome! We sat in the wine cellar and it was BEAUTIFUL! I loved it! Didn't get to make it up to the 3rd floor - martini bar, but I'm hoping to next time! Staff was polite and friendly and the drinks... more

Saturday night we visited the Colosseo not sure what to expect. We ordered a Chicken and Basil pasta dish and we were so impressed! It was probably the best Italian dish we have had in years! We loved the flavor as well as the presentation. The service was fantastic as well. We will be back. more

Admittedly, my wife and I have yet to order an entree at Colosseo since they opened their bar. It is not due to anything against the restaurant; we are just cheap. We find that when ordering an entree anywhere, we end up stuffing ourselves. Not to mention, we like our wine and beer which raises the bill well enough. However,... more

My wife and I just came home after eating Valentines Day dinner at Colosseo. What a disappointment. When I made the reservation I was told that each guest would receive a complimentary glass of champagne. We received ours, but the glasses were cheaply filled 1/4 of the way full. When my salad came to the table parts of it were... more

I live and work in downtown York in the center of the restaurant district. Since Colosseo opened its doors I have been a regular customer on, more or less, a weekly basis. I enjoy their excellent cuisine and excellent bar and wine cellar either immediately after work, if during the week, or immediately prior to attending a movie or theater... more

Went to Colosseo Ristorante Italiano this weekend and had a great time. The atmosphere in this place is so European-took me right out of York (Thanks!).Our meals started with a wonderful green salad and balsamic house dressing. Perfect. I had the Chicken Marsala with a creamy mushroom sauce-incredible. Can't wait to go back! more

My wife and I ordered the same salad. She ordered with dressing "on the side". I just ordered it. My salad was swimming in salad dressing. I ordered the lasagna because it is described on the menu as being made with a ragu bolognese and bechamel cream. The first time they served it to me, the dish was room temperature... more

My friend and I ate at Colosseo on a recent long weekend to the York area. It was elegant and the food was superb. Having been in Tuscany for a month in 2006, it rivaled the food we had there. I had a pasta dish with shrimp and vegetables in a white sauce. The dish was flavorful and literally burst... more