My partner and I happened upon the Cathedral Cafe on our way through Fayetteville on our way back from Lewisville to Charleston. We drove around the town square and saw this church which had been convert into a restaurant and thought, ew! Let's stop for an early lunch. Parking on the street was a bit tricky, but a space came... more

The sandwiches and milkshakes were excellent. So were the quesadillas (yes!). Service was friendly, and the ambience was of a coffee shop - casual and interesting. Lunch was definitely worth the trip. They are not open for dinner. more

If you are hungry and want fresh, delicious food--- the Cathedral Cafe is a "must visit" location in scenic Fayetteville. The clean environment and up-beat atmosphere make the Cafe a wonderful place to eat for locals, tourists & anyone seeking reasonably-priced and tasty meals! more

We always make it a point to stop at Cathedral Cafe for breakfast on our way home from our annual trip to raft the New and/or Gauley River(s). Great food in a place with some actual character and charm makes for a great end to the weekend. The pancakes are a must!! But get the short-stack unless you can put... more

Really good food, fun atmosphere, but slow service. I had the banana walnut pancakes - short stack - and I could only eat one because they were so big! The rest of our party tried various items and they were all good. more

I took family visiting from San Diego on a little road trip through Hawk's Nest State Park and the New River Gorge area. We took a little detour and ate at the Cathedral Cafe on the recommendation of one of the owners of the Mystery Hole (yes, we know the mystery and had a great laugh). There were a lot... more

If Columbus had a cafe like this, I would camp out on the doorstep. Do not order a full stack of pancakes unless you skipped dinner the day before! Fabulous frittatas, excellent muffins, pancakes, salads with homemade dressings, cobbler, and indeed the carrot cake is divinely inspired. I am less impressed by the cinnamon roll. Take your time ordering coffee;... more

Excellent food. During rafting season there may be a wait for breakfast. `Kid friendly. Sweet potato pancakes are great. Delicious,fresh baked carrot cake. more

Who would've guessed? In little Fayetteville, WV? A group of 6 of us were in Fayetteville to do some, (what else?) whitewater rafting and we drove through the historic district on Saturday night looking for a good, place (not a chain) to get some dinner and we saw the Cathedral Cafe-an interesting artsy place for breakfast. We made a note... more