We recently ate at Trattoria Stefano and had a less than stellar experience. We had a party of 8 with reservation for 7:30 and our table was not ready for quite a while...this was not our fault yet the staff seemed to treat as if that was so. We were most definately not a rowdy bunch with one or two... more

Recently eight friends out for a wives weekend picked Trattoria Stefano out of all the other restaurants in the area to dine at. The bartender was unfriendly to say the least. She seemed as though we were putting her off by ordering drinks. The waiter was exhausting, explaining every dish in great unnecessary depth. We also heard him say he... more

Great place for Italian cuisine if you're in the area, and more authentic than many of the Italian restaurants found in the big cities. Our waiter was very knowledgeable about the menu and gave great suggestions on wine pairings. Seemed to be the most happening spot in downtown Sheboygan, too. more

I've eaten here several times. The food isn't the best Italian food I've ever eaten. The waitstaff goes into great detail about how Stefano goes to the lengths of the world to obtain the finest ingredients for your meal. It's almost too much information. Almost as if he swims the ocean and spears just the perfect fish for your meal.... more

My boyfriend and I were staying in Sheboygan recently, We sought out Stefano's on the recommendation of a friend. I am so glad we did. Even though we called about 40 minutes before closing, the hostess assured us she could accommodate us. We weren't disappointed. The atmosphere was quaint, the service was fabulous and the food was superb. My boyfriend... more

My large and rowdy group is still talking about what a wonderful time we had at Stefano's. Yes, the fodd is wonderful, and the service is even better. Several of us couldn't decide what to drink, so the bartender guided us through what we like in wine, then delivered wonderful vino to us. Our waiter (a professional and a gentleman)... more

Really, really good. Surprisingly good. more

Excelent! more

A hidden gem! Quite possibly the best italian in the region....go with the chef's specials and you won't be disappointed. Worth the 2 hour drive from chicago! more