Who would have thought that a place with the name of an Irish pub would have such a great wine list and menu? We tried it because it was literally the only place open at 9:00 p.m. (things close early in this small village). The food was superb -- apps, salad, entree and dessert -- as was the service. All... more

We had such a good dinner at McKays on our last night of vacation (last week). There three of us, and we all had wonderful meals. Especially to be recommended was the fried chicken liver appetizer. My companions both raved. I particularly can't stop thinking about the mac and cheese with lobster. We were seated promptly, having made a reservation,... more

Sat on the heated outdoor porch on a chilly September night. Duck egg rolls were great, mushroom pasta special was devine, and pork chop was mammoth. Service could have been a tad bit more attentive, but I think our girl was just helping out due to an unsual late-season rush on a Sunday night. Will definitely be back... more

We ate here last night & had a great beet salad with goat cheese and lobster. The lobster was a challenge - 1st time - but none the less good. Clean and good service. more

Entres and prices range from great pub chow to fine dinners. Comfortable environment. Crab cakes were just grand, better than I had in Maryland. Clam chowder, hard to beat my own but I have to admit, their's was awesome! Shephard's pie, nice, really nice. Irish beef stew, tastes just like what I had in the pubs in Belfast, Ireland, yum!... more

We enjoyed the atmosphere and service was attentive, however the meal was somewhat bland. more

We sat outside on a beautiful evening. The trees are lit up with christmas lights, and made a quaint setting. Our waitress was very good, and the food was excellent. open for dinner more

McKay's offers seating outdoors, on a porch and inside an old house in Bar Harbor; excellent and fresh food that was a great alternative to Maine's ubiquitous lobsters/fried clams/etc. Our waiter seemed to be a dope-smoking college kid on break who looked like Shaggy from Scooby Doo and knew about as much about the menu; we ended up having a... more

We were greeted and seated in a timly manner. Very hot day in Bar Harbor Aug 16th 2009, 90 degs. For a family of 5 we had Ginger ale with a black thing floating in the glass. *GROSS*. Baked brie that was the best thing we had .... House salad and ceasar salad was good very small in portion for... more