We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.

New York City

Free Newsletter

Interested in New York City?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for New York City each week.

  • Save Croton Reservoir Tavern
  • E-mail this page

Croton Reservoir Tavern


4.0 of 5 stars 8 ratings  |  Write a review
  • Cuisines: American
  • Neighbourhood: Times Square/Theater District
  • 108 W 40th St, New York City, NY 10018
  • (212) 997-6835

Reviews you can trust

100% Recommend
Excellent
Very Good
Average
Poor
1
Terrible
0
Rating summary
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere
[ Date ] [ Rating ]
Save Review
5 of 5 stars
Orlando, FL
7 Jul 2009

Found the Croton Reservoir Tavern just by walking past on West 40th Street, headed to Bryant Park across the street. Liked the look of the exterior, the menu in the window, and the classy/classic interior. Lots of dark wood, stained glass, wrought iron and leather. Flat screens showing sports over the bar (volume off). A solid American grill menu. We... more

Save Review
4 of 5 stars
NYC
2 Jun 2009

I did't expect much from a "tavern" but was very surprised. It's only 2 blocks from Times Square and thank goodness we got away from those over priced, over touristy places. Great atmosphere, great Happy Hour from what we saw downstairs, and we had a surprisingly delicious dinner, actually not too surprising after we walked inside. Very professional and pleasant... more

Save Review
Facebook Connect
3 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor reviewer on Facebook
25 Feb 2008

I mostly go here because its convenient to where I work and it doesn't get too loud during weekday lunch. Food is not bad, but nothing to draw you back on its own merits. more

Save Review
Facebook Connect
4 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor reviewer on Facebook
7 Feb 2008

You could easily pass right by this great spot in the midtown hustle & bustle...but don't! The bar provides a nice spot to catch up with friends...but more importantly is the FOOD! Suprisingly good! Beware that the downstairs seating where it would be quiet always seems to be utilized for a private party... leaving you sitting along the right hand... more

Save Review
Facebook Connect
4 of 5 stars
A TripAdvisor reviewer on Facebook
30 Dec 2007

Great place for a relaxed lunch. Haven't been here in the evening but it looks like it'd be great for happy hour. more

Save Review
4 of 5 stars
Vancouver, BC
2 Oct 2006
1
person found this review helpful

I found this restaurant on opentable and took a stab at it. When you go between 4-7pm do ask for the pre-theatre menu which is a great deal at $30 for 3 courses! The entrees are the same as the a la carte menu and typically "American" sized portions i.e. huge! Grilled skirt steak absolutely delicious. Simply grilled salmon a... more

Write Your Own Restaurant Review

Been to Croton Reservoir Tavern? Share your experiences!

Write a Review
Add Photos
Add Videos

Do You Own Croton Reservoir Tavern?

TripAdvisor has free and easy resources to help you enhance your listing and promote your property.

  • Start Here - Visit Your Owners' Centre
  • Add Photo
  • Add Video

Croton Reservoir Tavern Address

108 W 40th St, New York City, NY 10018
Tel: (212) 997-6835
* Restaurant price information is based on meal cost per person, excluding drinks, tax and tip.