The menu described tempting dishes and we ordered a variety of seafoods and cooking methods. Presentation was good but we found that it all tasted the same: salty or greasy!! It almost seemed that everything was soaked in brine before being covered in too much sauce or fried. Very disappointing. more

I have dined at the Coldwater several times and found the food and service exceptional. If a gentleman named Keoki still works there, try to be seated in his section. We found Keoki knew what wine, fish and dessert to recommend for the ideal meal. The halibut on heirloom tomato salad was awesome. Swordfish was not as good, but still... more

My partner and I went for dinner around 6pm. The waitress gave a spiel about how they specialize in local, fresh seafood, but do offer some non-seafood options. My partner ordered the rack of lamb ($37) with a side of wedge fries($4.50). I had trouble deciding between the special (halibut with cajun spices over grilled endive) or the paella (shrimp,... more